Not polling PD [PlatformIO Arduino]

[aaronjamt]

Describe the bug
Using this library to build a Control Panel on the Arduino Uno R4 Renesas platform (using PlatformIO), the PD is never polled. I believe this applies to more platforms, likely including all embedded devices, but I'm not entirely sure of that.

Expected behavior
The microcontroller would poll the reader every ~50ms

Observed behavior
The microcontroller never polls the reader and thus never receives the message that a card was scanned, a keypad button was pressed, or any other event.

Additional context
The cause of this issue is as follows:

• osdp_cp.c calls osdp_millis_since() to check whether it should poll
• osdp_millis_since() calls osdp_millis_now(), which calls millis_now() which is defined in goToMain/c-utils
• millis_now() calls usec_now(), which calls gettimeofday()
• On (at least) this platform, the preprocessor condition #elif defined(__BARE_METAL__) is met, meaning gettimeofday() is defined at line 167 as:

int gettimeofday(struct timeval * tp, struct timezone * tzp)
{
	ARG_UNUSED(tzp);
	tp->tv_sec = 0;
	tp->tv_usec = 0;
	return 0;
}

• As a result, osdp_millis_since() is never aware that any time has passed, and thus the initial conditional never triggers a CMD_POLL.

[sidcha]

@aaronjamt Thanks for the detailed issue description. There is a slight variation in call path when platformIO is used.

• osdp_millis_now() is defined as a weak symbol.
• For platformIO, there is a strong definition of that symbol which uses mills().
• And we compile that file in platformIO so the weak symbol should be overridden.

So, we directly short circuit that path and should reach mills() earlier. I see your proposed solution in c-utils#34 also does something similar. Can you please try to look at why weak symbol resolution does not work for you?

[aaronjamt]

I'm not very familiar with PlatformIO so I'm not entirely sure how to find the root cause, but I'll see if I can find anything.

[sidcha]

Closing due to inactivity.